ANDREW JON! You know you are in trouble when your Mom yells at you using your first and middle name. Andy is a thumb sucker.


Alyssa never sucked her thumb. She never had a pacifier. Alex sucked his thumb but was able to stop on his own. If Andy could permanently have his thumb in his mouth, he would be one happy camper. I’ve received lots of advice. Most said they or someone they know sucked their thumb until 4th grade or sometime later in life, and all is well now.
OK, whatever. This is MY son. I’m the Mom and I decide what is best for my kids. He needs to stop! There are lots of different tools out there claiming to stop the habit. You name it, we’ve tried it. The fingernail polish didn’t slow him down one bit – his thumb immediately went into his mouth. Band-aids and tape, he’d sneak off by himself, remove the obstacle, then return proudly displaying his accomplishment. The more I fought, the more he protested. We found the thumb-guard online. Guaranteed or your money back. Basically it’s a pliable plastic that fits over the thumb and hooks on the wrist with a hospital band. A little pricey, but with the money back guarantee, you can’t go wrong. We were off to a great start. Though it looked like a torture device and generated dirty looks from the self-appointed judges of the “Parent of the Year” contest, I didn’t care. He wasn’t sucking his thumb.
Finally, something was working.
Until… he figured out he could use his teeth to stretch the plastic device enough to get his thumb out, get his fix (he just couldn’t kick the habit), then use his teeth again to place it back on. Andrew Jon!
After talking to the pediatric dentist, it was time for an appliance. He’s already “open,” meaning his top and bottom teeth don’t meet (see picture), and if it continues, it will lead to a speech impairment.
The dentist made plaster impressions of his little mouth and added spacers to make room for the $500 dental appliance, known as the “retainer.” We called it that because Alyssa has a retainer and thought it would be easier for him to understand. Yeah baby, he can’t get his thumb in there now.
A couple days later, the whole appliance fell out. I don’t think the assistant used enough cement. After another trip to the dentist, his retainer was back in place. OK, now SUCCESS, finally!!
Andy never complained about the device. He couldn’t manipulate it or take it out. It wasn’t fun watching him eat. He was constantly sticking his fingers in to remove the food that was caught in it. It was very similar to seeing a plumber pull out the soupy, shredded remnants from a clogged garbage disposal. Again, I didn’t care. It was working. His attempts to suck his thumb had long since subsided.

Until… approximately four months later, I was outside working in the yard. Andy comes running out yelling at me, “I want this retainer out right now! It’s hard to eat.” His first complaint ever about it.
“Are you done sucking your thumb?”
Without a response, he runs back into the house only to return moments later with part of the device in his hand.
I reach into his mouth and can feel rough edges where it had been attached. Fearing his tongue will be sliced to shreds, we immediately head to the dentist’s office. They have NEVER had one break like that, EVER. Only my son! We decide to keep it off for now in hopes that he’s overcome his addiction.
”ANDREW JON!” Here we go again!
“What?” as he quickly removes his thumb with the orneriest grin ever.
“Keep it out or I’m calling the dentist.”
About a week later, the call is made. The dentist is out for the next three weeks. Great, just great. Plenty of time for the addiction to become full fledge again.
The appointment is approaching, I’m excited, Tim bursts my bubble, “You aren’t going to have that thing put back in, are you?”
“Excuse me!” I’m trying to keep to my guns, but in reality, I had been caving all along.
“It’s such a pain for him to eat.”
“I’ve been thinking the same thing. He’s also a lot better now than he used to be. At least when I yell at him, he keeps it out. Give me some time to think about it.”
The next day I get Andy alone and decide to discuss it with him.
“Andy, do you want your retainer back in?”
“Yeah.”
“You do?”
“Yeah, will the dentist be mad at me?” The dentist has had a few stern conversations with him about his addiction.
“Well, he won’t be happy and he’ll probably share that with you.”
“NO, I don’t want it.”
“OK, let’s see how you do. You’ve been doing much better and as long as you don’t suck your thumb, we’ll keep it out.”
“OK, Mommy.”
It’s been about two weeks and I haven’t seen his thumb in his mouth since this conversation. Yeah Andy!! You’ve overcame your addiction. You are stronger!!